Ditch SMART Goals: A Revolutionary Approach to Educational Goal-Setting

Goals That Actually Work for Special Education

The SMART goal framework is a relic that needs to be retired – especially in special education. Let's rewind to 1981. George T. Doran, a corporate consultant, introduced the SMART goals framework in a management review article, explicitly designing it for business performance management. These goals were meant to help managers create precise, measurable objectives in a corporate setting – think sales targets, productivity metrics, and quarterly reports.

Fast forward four decades, and this business-centric framework has somehow become the standard for educational goal-setting, particularly in special education. It's like using a wrench to perform surgery – fundamentally misaligned with the purpose. These rigid, corporate-inspired goals have been suffocating the potential of students with special needs, turning individualized education into a box-checking exercise rather than a transformative journey of growth and potential.

Today, we're going to revolutionize how we think about educational goals.

We'll explore:

• Why SMART goals fail our students

• The ALIGNED framework: A student-centered alternative

• Practical steps to implement meaningful educational objectives

If you're a parent fighting for your child's educational potential, struggling with IEP limitations, and seeking a more holistic approach to goal-setting, then here are the resources you need to dig into:

Weekly Resource List:

• Quarterly Progress Review Worksheet - A comprehensive tracking tool that helps assess your student’s academic, social, and emotional progress

• At-Home Skill Development Tracker - A practical daily and weekly guide for you to support and track your child's independence and skill development in home-based routines and activities

• Strength-Based Goal Setting Template - A holistic approach to goal setting that focuses on identifying and leveraging a child's unique strengths, interests, and motivations to create meaningful and supportive developmental objectives

• Personal Interest and Motivation Tracker - An in-depth exploration tool designed to map a child's interests, understand their motivation style, and discover potential learning opportunities aligned with their passions

5 Things to Transform Educational Goals Even if You Feel Stuck in the System

The traditional approach has failed our students, but you have the power to change that.

1. Understand the Fundamental Flaw of SMART Goals

SMART goals (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) sound logical, but they're fundamentally broken when applied to education. In a business context, these goals might track widget production or sales numbers. But our children aren't widgets. They're complex, dynamic human beings with unique learning paths, challenges, and potentials that can't be confined to a spreadsheet.

2. Recognize the Humanity Behind the Metrics

Every time we reduce a student's progress to a numerical target, we strip away their individuality. A SMART goal might say, "Student will answer reading comprehension questions with 80% accuracy in 4 out of 5 trials." But what does that actually mean? It doesn't capture the student's love of storytelling, their unique way of processing information, or the ultimate life goal for the student.

3. Embrace the ALIGNED Framework

Our alternative isn't just a different acronym – it's a completely different philosophy:

• Achievable/Assessable: Goals that are realistic and meaningful

• Longitudinal: Looking at long-term growth, not just short-term gains

• Individualized: Tailored to each student's unique strengths and challenges

• Generalizable: Skills that transfer across multiple contexts

• Non-restrictive: Promoting full access and inclusion

• Educationally-Relevant: Connected to genuine learning and personal growth

• Data-Informed: Using objective evidence, not arbitrary standards

4. Challenge the Status Quo

Parents and educators must become active advocates. This means:

• Questioning goals that feel more like corporate KPIs than educational support

• Pushing for goals that celebrate progress, not just measure it

• Recognizing that growth is non-linear and deeply personal

5. Implement a Holistic Approach

Goal-setting should be a collaborative, dynamic process. Involve your child. Listen to their experiences. Consider their emotional well-being, their interests, and their unique way of interacting with the world.

That's it.

Here's what you learned today:

• SMART goals are a corporate tool, not an educational solution

• Goals should be student-centered and holistic

• You have the power to advocate for a more meaningful approach

Take Action: Review your child's current goals through the ALIGNED lens. What needs to change? What potential is being overlooked?

Every small shift brings us closer to truly supporting our students' unique journeys. Empowerment starts with reimagining what's possible.

All the best,

Megan

Let’s connect on socials: Twitter/X | Instagram | Facebook | TikTok | Bluesky

Looking for a particular resource? Shoot me an email and let me know and you may just see that resource included in next week’s newsletter.

PS... If you're enjoying SPED Code, please consider referring this edition to a friend.